Professor Dagmar Schäfer's Review of China's Transition to Modernity

-

I have reviewed about ten books for different journals and read many book reviews in the past two decades. I am pretty certain that I have received a "glowing" review from Professor Dagmar Schäfer. What I am about to say is not really a disclaimer but an appreciation of how academic review system actually works in my case. I never met Professor Schäfer and have virtually no professional relationship with her.

Of course Professor Schäfer's reputation proceeds her. I have read and admired her award-winning book and assigned part of it to my undergraduate students before. I have also heard good things about her. For instance, my co-editor Johan Elverskog spoke highly of her work.

More importantly, China's Transition to Modernity had not been reviewed by a historian of science until hers appears on Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies in June 2018. To be recognized and appreciated by an outstanding fellow historian whose expertise falls squarely in my field is quite gratifying. The questions she raises also resonate with me.

Click here to read her review.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

UCSC seminar on early modern China–Part 1

-
I am reading some recent scholarship with six graduate students in the fall quarter. The first set of readings includes Frederic Wakeman's  “ China and the Seventeenth-century World Crisis ," the first two chapters of Wai-yee Li's Women and National Trauma in Late Imperial Chinese Literature , and James Frankel's chapter “Making Manchus and Muslims” in the edited volume Cosmopolitanism in China. The Chinese collaboration For the previous millennium (1000–2000), China was twice conquered by an alien minority. The first time was Mongol conquest and the second the Manchu. The Mongol Yuan dynasty was short-lived because, among other reasons, the Mongol rulers displaced the Chinese elites institutionally and deprived them of political power. The Manchu, on the other hand, shared power with the Chinese elites, kept their land and privilege , and promised them more. Wakeman provides the following statements regarding how the ethnic Chinese elites who worked for the new...
Read more

The Scholar's Robe

-
Image
My essay " The Scholar's Robe " is published on Frontiers of History in China . Check it out! The Scholar's Robe will be published again in the conference volume of International Research Center for Japanese Studies ( Nichibunken ). I am quite impressed by its format. Click here to check it out! A photo of all participants in Nichibunken conference, Kyoto, 2/19–2/21, 2016.
Read more

UCSC seminar–Part 2

-
The second set of readings includes the first chapter of Rosenthal and Wong's  Before and Beyond Divergence: The Politics of Economic Change in China and Europe , John Elliott's "A Europe of Composite Monarchies," and the second part of R. Kent Guy's Qing Governors and Their Provinces: The Evolution of Territorial Administration in China, 1644-1796 . The Language of Union: Conquest, territorial management (such river work and transportation), ecological characteristics, and provincial governance (such as tax collection and disaster relief) all featured in Guy's  Qing Governors and Their Provinces . We only read the second half of the book. The first half is about the extraordinarily active appointment and dismissal of Qing governors, assessment of their competence, and central coordination of territorial control, tactical and logistical concerns of border defence, revenue collection for the imperial coffer, etc. Elite activism on behalf of the Qing stat...
Read more